LEASE REVIEW: A Priority for Launching a Restaurant

Contact Neufeld Legal for restaurant/bar legal matters at 403-400-4092 / 905-616-8864 or Chris@NeufeldLegal.com

A critical and often legally complex priority that anyone contemplating the launch of a restaurant is a thorough review of the intended commercial property lease agreement. This legal document, which may initially seem like standard boilerplate, is arguably the single most important contractual obligation a restaurant owner will undertake. Far from being a mere formality, the lease agreement determines the financial viability, operational flexibility, and long-term security of the business. Signing it without expert scrutiny is a profound risk, potentially locking the owner into unfavorable terms that can lead to unforeseen costs, crippling restrictions, and even business failure down the line.

One of the primary reasons a pre-signing review is non-negotiable is to meticulously scrutinize the financial clauses hidden within the agreement. Commercial leases, particularly for retail spaces like restaurants, often contain complex and opaque expense structures beyond the base rent. Terms like Common Area Maintenance fees, property taxes, insurance, and utility responsibilities must be clearly defined. Without a detailed review, an owner may inadvertently agree to pay an inflated percentage of the building's operating expenses, or worse, be responsible for costly capital repairs to the property's structure, expenses that are far beyond the scope of normal business operations. A skilled professional can identify vague or excessively broad financial obligations, negotiate clear caps on annual Common Area Maintenance increases, and ensure the restaurant's prorated share of expenses is calculated fairly, thereby safeguarding the business's crucial early-stage cash flow.

For a restaurant, the lease must explicitly grant the necessary operational permissions and freedoms essential for the business model. This includes the 'Permitted Use' clause, which must be broad enough to cover all current and future aspects of the dining operation, such as serving alcohol, catering, hosting private events, or even offering outdoor patio seating. A simple clause that only permits "restaurant operations" might be too restrictive. Furthermore, the lease is the place to negotiate crucial physical alterations, such as the installation of kitchen venting, grease traps, fire suppression systems, and heavy-duty electrical wiring. Without prior, explicit landlord approval for these specific, restaurant-critical build-out items, often requiring significant financial outlay, an owner could be forced to remove them or face immediate default, making the entire business non-functional before it even opens.

The lease review is also the only opportunity to establish and protect the restaurant's competitive positioning within a multi-tenant property. A restaurant owner must seek to include an "Exclusive Use" clause that prevents the landlord from leasing adjacent spaces to direct competitors (e.g., preventing a similar style of cuisine or a specific type of service like a coffee shop). Conversely, the owner must be wary of any restrictive clauses placed on their own operations by the landlord to protect existing tenants. Ignoring this step can lead to a scenario where a nearly identical business opens next door shortly after, directly cannibalizing the restaurant's customer base. Legal review ensures that the competitive landscape of the location is locked in and favorable to the restaurant’s success before the doors even open.

Finally, the lease is a long-term commitment, and its terms must address the entire lifecycle of the business, including potential challenges and an eventual exit. Key clauses regarding the right to assign or sublease the space are vital for a future sale of the business, as an unassignable lease drastically reduces the restaurant's market value. Furthermore, clauses concerning renewal options, default conditions, and remedies for both parties need careful balancing. A poorly written default clause, for instance, might give the landlord the power to evict the tenant over minor, curable violations. By having the lease professionally reviewed, restaurant owners gain clarity on their long-term obligations and rights, securing a viable exit strategy and ensuring that their investment is protected against arbitrary or punitive actions from the landlord throughout the entire lease term.

For knowledgeable and experienced legal representation in reviewing and negotiating the terms of your restaurant's lease agreement, and other important legal matters related to starting, operating and managing a restaurant or bar, together with a raft of legal intricacies and dilemmas that may arise, contact restaurant lawyer Christopher Neufeld at 403-400-4092 [Alberta], 905-616-8864 [Ontario] or Chris@NeufeldLegal.com.

Restaurant Lawyer - About our Legal Practice